14 October 2008
1 Oct
Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar (SRB) is the best chance for a pick-up by the New Democrats in Saskatchewan.
The incumbent, Carol Skelton, who enjoyed a good deal of personal popularity (and was at pains to associate herself with the Conservative brand in any of her communications) is not running again. In her place, the Conservatives nominated Kelly Block, one of the higher-ups of the ruling Saskatchewan Party (i.e. Conservative Party), former rural town mayor, and a member of several health boards. She was nominated this past summer by the party.
Nettie Wiebe was re-nominated in January 2007 to represent the New Democratic Party for a second time, she ran and lost to Skelton in 2006. A farmer, professor, and activist, Nettie has been hard at work in the riding for the past 3.5 years building both the NDP brand and her name. In particular, her and her team gave much focus to the rural portion of the riding over the past 1.5 years leading up to the election.
Roy Bluehorn was the last minute nominee for the Liberal Party and is a young aboriginal policy analyst with ties to the urban portion of the riding. There are also candidates running under the Green, Christian Hertiage Party (vote against immorality!), and the Libertarian Party.
The battle in this election will be between Nettie Wiebe and Kelly Block, with both camps running high resource campaigns. The lack of an incumbent this time around would seem to give the name recognition to Nettie Wiebe over Kelly Block.
A quick look at the 2006 results broken down between the urban and rural portion of the riding gives an idea of where the main contenders stand heading towards October 14th:
Rural Saskatoon Total Voters 11446 36752 Vote Total 7961 21392 Turnout 69.6 58.2 - Total Votes Rural Saskatoon Green 153 585 C.H. 41 217 Lib 528 3048 Con 5140 8191 NDP 2125 9287 - % Vote Rural Saskatoon Green 1.9 2.7 C.H. 0.5 1.0 Lib 6.6 14.2 Con 64.6 38.3 NDP 26.7 43.4
The difference between Skelton and Wiebe in 2006 was 1919 votes. While Skelton far and away carried the rural vote (64.6 to 26.7%), the rural vote only accounted for approximately 27% of total votes cast. However, the Conservative were able to hold there own in the city, and along with a just-strong-enough showing from the Liberals, were able to hold their ground in the urban portions. However, what really hurt the NDP in 2006 were some extremely low voter turn numbers in the urban portion. On average 58% of urban voters cast a ballot, while nearly 70% of rural voters showed up on election day. What the presented data does not show are the numerous urban polls where the NDP took > 50% of the popular vote (to 30% for the Cons) but only saw 40-45% voter turnout (not including the advance polls). In these polls the NDP was out-pacing the Conservatives by 100 to 300 votes. When added across 50+ polling stations, 1919 votes becomes a very small number.
A few on-the-ground observations of the campaign so far:
- The Liberals are nearly non-existent in the riding as our the Greens
- In the core neighbourhoods (Caswell, Hudson Bay Park, Westmount, Riversdale, etc…) for every Con sign there are between 4-7 NDP signs on lawns (thankfully no sign wars have erupted on main boulevards), I’ve seen 1 sign for the Liberals, Greens, and Christian Heritage Party.
- Both Kelly Block’s and Nettie Wiebe’s campaign offices are busy throughout the day with a good deal of volunteers in each
- Media exposure has been good for both, though Nettie seems to be getting more than Kelly as she is the goto person in Saskatchewan for the NDP
- Both candidates have excellent websites with all the bells and whistles
So what does this mean for the NDP and Conservatives on October 14th?
Well, first I will lay out a few assumptions (feel free to debate their merits), based on what I have seen on the ground as this race has progressed (I live in the riding):
- The Liberal vote will decline from 2006, a less visible candidate and a better awareness by voters that Nettie is the only choice to block a Conservative win again
- The Green Party is non-existent (in 2006 they actually saw a decrease in their vote from 2004) both in the riding and in the province and at best could increase their 2006 total (2.6%) by 1%
- The Conservatives will lose some ground from 2006 as they are without an incumbent and are now running on their record
- The NDP gains (19-20% nationally) will hold through to Election Day
Taking all of that into account I would suggest that a 3-4% increase in the NDP rural vote is not out of question and might be an underestimation. Additionally, a 5% swing in the urban portion is also very likely with the Liberals dropping from their 14% in 2006 to about 10% and the Conservatives dropping a 2-3% as well.
Just a 7% swing towards the NDP within the urban portion of the riding would hand Nettie the win, or a 3% increase in the rural and a 5% increase in the urban.
Though I am not willing to pick a winner in Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar at this time, I think the numbers indicate for themselves that this will be an extremely close race to watch on Election night and that there is a very good chance that the New Democrats will carry the day. However, they will have to do a better job at pulling the urban voters out to the polls. WIthout doing this the Conservatives are likely to sneak by once again.
_______
Cross-posted on my blog (www.seaninsaskatchewan.wordpress.com)

Conservative Party
Liberal Party
New Democratic Party
Bloc Québécois
Green Party
Christian Heritage
Progressive Canadian
Marijuana Party
Marxist-Leninist Party
Canadian Action Party
Communist Party
Libertarian Party
First Peoples Party
Western Block Party
Animal Alliance Party
neorhino.ca
10 Responses for "Sask Ridings: Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar, Revisited"
[...] Cross posted at DemocraticSPACE [...]
[...] she campaigns in Saskatoon. I am really looking forward to this opportunity. I sure hope that the conventional wisdom for this riding turns out to be false! addthis_url = [...]
I see the election coverage here is just as deficient as in the Star Phoenix. Do you know who Kevin Stricker is? How about Marcel Bourassa? Have you ever even been to my riding?
If that fringe party, the Greens get coverage, why not the other fringe parties? You do not get to decide who is mainstream and who is not.
Sean Shaw, the past president of the Saskatoon–Wanuskewin riding association for the NDP and current member of the executive for Carol skelton can be as biased as he wants.
You have to realize that being neutral simply isn’t a requirement for writing on this site, and that fact isn’t hidden here at all.
um, I am not on Carol Skelton’s Exec or any other Conservative organization.
That would be Nettie Wiebe’s executive.
I included all of the results from the 2006 election via the Elections Canada website. There were 5 parties in that election (NDP, Con, Lib, Green, CH). This time there is also a Libertarian candidate (Mr. Stricker) and an independent (Mr. Barsky).
However, I only the parties that will have an impact on the final results in my analysis. Personally, I don’t see the Greens, CH, Libertarian, or the independent candidates as having an impact, though I do applaud them for putting their names forward.
I also live in the riding, and know it well.
Oops. . . I’m not sure how I confused Nettie Wiebe and Carol Skelton. At any rate, I do know who you are. Honestly, with the number of disenfranchised conservatives in the I likely could tilt the balance a bit, but it would involve a lot of work for which Nettie Wiebe would be the main beneficiary. Not worth my time.
What is this all about ? Got this from the kelly Block web site?
Kelly Block has my full support as the Conservative Candidate in Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar. Kelly’s strong, proven leadership in municipal government and on the Health Board will be an asset when serving the residents of the riding.
Carol Teichrob
Former NDP Cabinet Minister &Â Kelly Block Supporter
Prediction:
Conservative vote will decline marginally based on a small amount of people who will refrain from supporting Kelly Block who previously supported Skelton.
Nettie Wiebe’s vote will stay virtually the same, maybe with a slight increase or decrease, but not gaining enough to defeat the conservative candidate.
Liberal vote will increase, as will the Green vote.
The Liberal Candidate in 2006 didn’t exist, and didn’t run a campaign, had no media coverage, and no government experience or connection.
Roy Bluehorn has plenty of experience and connection to Ottawa. Has worked for Chris Axworthy, Gary Merasty, Bob Rae, Stephane Dion, among others.
He has also received considerable coverage and media exposure in all parts of the riding, through all mediums, probably because of the reasons in the above paragraph.
So it seems strange that a paper candidate with no experience who received a base of 12% would fair better than a candidate with great experience, strong ties to the riding, who has received favourable media, and worked for and with Chris Axworthy the last non-Conservative MP for SRB.
It’s obvious that the campaign resources are limited for the Liberals, but I think the constituents are more adept at determining the calibre of their candidates than by judging solely on the presence of lawn signs.
So to say that the base would decline from 2006 seems a little bit dismissive of a very qualified candidate, considering the previous paper candidate, and the fact that Bob Rae went out of his way to attach his name to Roy Bluehorn and his qualifications.
I’m sure you have or would argue that Bob wasted time in Saskatoon, when I would say it shows the unity of the Liberal Party of Canada and reveals the confidence in Roy Bluehorn’s qualifications.
ELECTION DAY IS:
TUESDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2008
7:30 a.m. to 7:30 p.m.
Go A Vote Make a differenence In this election every votes counts!
Leave a reply below or start a thread in the discussion forums
Note: Sometimes people try to portray more support for their candidate or their perspective in the comments section by posing as different people. If you attempt to do this, we will delete all of your comments.Update: despite the above warning, people are attempting to use multiple aliases, so we are now moderating all comments to check against possible abuses. We apologize for this inconvenience, however we will work to get comments posted as soon as possible.