14 October 2008
10 Oct
Look at these numbers:
Nationally, however, the party appears to have stopped its week-long slide and come to rest with between 33 and 35 per cent support from decided voters – a shade below the 36 per cent of the vote it won in 2006, allowing it to form a minority government.
What does all this really mean? Very little, to tell the truth. First of all, polls are never accurate. To achieve any real representative accuracy or significance, polling companies would have to poll at least 3,500 people for each poll, rather than only 1,200, 1,000 or 800-900. Given the sample sizes in Canadian polls, all of them are for the birds.
Second, there is the issue of Canada’s undemocratic and antiquated first-past-the-post system – i.e., the winner takes all, as they say. Even if the polling numbers are accurate, which they are not, and we assume that the Tories will get, say, 34%, they can still form a majority government. All they have to do is win by at least one vote in 155 ridings, and the majority is in place. Or to put it in more drastic terms, if they obtained as little as 10% of the votes in 155 ridings, and 10% happens to be the highest count for any of the candidates in the ridings, they would also win a majority.
Always keep in mind what happened in the provincial election in Alberta this March: with only 22% of the electorate supporting them, the Alberta Tories formed a majority government, holding 72 of 83 seats (!).
Finally, the above numbers may not be all that accurate, as I said:
University of B.C. political scientist Fred Cutler, a voting specialist, warned that polling numbers early in a campaign can be suspect and that the decline in support is probably exaggerated.
It is for this reason that it will be a long time before any of the mainstream parties will ever agree to change to a system of proportional representation. As they surely see it: Why fix it if it ain’t broke?

Conservative Party
Liberal Party
New Democratic Party
Bloc Québécois
Green Party
Christian Heritage
Progressive Canadian
Marijuana Party
Marxist-Leninist Party
Canadian Action Party
Communist Party
Libertarian Party
First Peoples Party
Western Block Party
Animal Alliance Party
neorhino.ca
2 Responses for "Polls, schmolls"
Thanks, but if I had to choose between all of Canada’s polling firms and Werner Patels, I choose the polling firms.
Ditto for “University of B.C. political scientist Fred Cutler.”
Polls are tricky things, and this election they hve been misused far too much. Examples:
- Where the hell did the reporting of “undecided” voters go? This used to be a very important figure, only now it never gets mentioned.
- Urban/rural differences – this meausre is more important than the age difference, probably as big as the gender difference. More importantly, even if in size it does not vary so much, it does have a greater impact on how seats are won and lost. For example, in BC much is made of the low Liberal numbers, but it’s almost all urban. I have seen BC polls, but not any split between urban Greater Vancouver and the rest of BC. I’m sure the parties are aware of the different pattern of oppositon in different regions, but the media is being a bit deceptive when they characterize it as something so general.
- This election, there have actually been far too many polls reported, and the polls have become an issue. That’s wasted a lot of air-time which could have actually been spent on issues instead – yeah, I blame the lazy media for it. “Rolling polls” and “daily totals” and “trend adjustments” – all quite manipulative.
Leave a reply below or start a thread in the discussion forums
Note: Sometimes people try to portray more support for their candidate or their perspective in the comments section by posing as different people. If you attempt to do this, we will delete all of your comments.Update: despite the above warning, people are attempting to use multiple aliases, so we are now moderating all comments to check against possible abuses. We apologize for this inconvenience, however we will work to get comments posted as soon as possible.